Talk:Trophies

New Layout

I'd like some input on the trophy page. Do you think there is a better way to set up the page? I don't think the uses listing is all that useful. Every trophy will list exactly what it is for on its page. I think the best way to layout this page would be to somehow break up the trophies into groups, and have just the icons and trophies listed under those groups, in multiple columns (like most new items lists on patch pages). The question is, how do we break up the trophies? Alphabetical, or by source/type?

Here is an example of the layout I am talking about, using the first few trophies currently listed:

File:A Huge Lump of Coal icon.png	A Huge Lump of Coal		A Large Mnemosyne	File:A Small Mnemosyne icon.png	A Small Mnemosyne		A Tiny Mnemosyne
File:A Perfect Snowman Eye icon.png	A Perfect Snowman Eye	File:Adolescent Ivory Gromnie Eye icon.png	Adolescent Ivory Gromnie Eye	File:Adolescent Rust Gromnie Eye icon.png	Adolescent Rust Gromnie Eye		Aluvian Leg
File:Ancient Empyrean Trinket icon.png	Ancient Empyrean Trinket		Ancient Falatacot Trinket

--An Adventurer 21:58, 27 October 2008 (CDT)

---

I am leaning towards grouping them by types. Perhaps we can split trophies into 3 different pages, with a banner linking them together like the quest page.

Page 1) Trophy by Creature Type:
Armoredillo, Banderling, Burun, Cattle (Cow+Auroch) Carenzi, Chicken, Crystal, Drudge, Eater, Elemental (all types grouped), Fiun, Ghost, Golem, Grievver, Gromnie, Human, Idol, Knath, Lugian (gotrok+reg), Margul, Mattekar, Mite, Moar, Moarsman, Monouga, Mosswart, Mukkir, Niffis, Olthoi (reg and PT), Penguin, Phyntos Wasp, Rabbit, Rat, Reedshark (+shallows shark), Remoran, Ruschk, Scarecrow & Snowman, Sclavus, Shadow, Shreth, Siraluun, Skeleton, Sleech, Statues, Thrungus, Tumerok (reg+aun+hea), Tusker, Undead, Ursuin, Virindi, Virindi Constructs (doll+rift+marionette+simulacrum), Wisp

Page 2) Trophy by Area:
Caul, Dark Isle, Graveyard, Halataen Isles (ToD stuff), Marae Lassel (ACDM Stuff), Valley of Death, Vissidal Isle, what ever else

Page 3) Trophy by Crafter:
Collecter, Wing Collector, Trophy Smith, etc.

Trophies would be listed on every page they apply to, and on page 2 and 3, the same trophy could be listed under multiple categories.

Trophies - Trophies by Creature - Trophies by Area - Trophies by Collector - Category:Trophy

--An Adventurer 22:32, 27 October 2008 (CDT)

Previous Layout work notes

Alphabetized up to Black Stone

--An Adventurer 19:06, 28 June 2008 (CDT)

---

I've redone the trophy page. The table of contents was way too long, so I have created one large sortable table instead.

Things that still need to get done:

1. I did not re-order the items. all trophies should be listed alphabetically as the base.
2. I did not fill in any of the uses.
3. Still lots of missing trophies.
4. Nearly all icons are the wrong size (should be 32x32), low quality, named incorrectly, and in .jpg format instead of .png

--An Adventurer 13:53, 21 June 2008 (CDT)